Bob Garwick's Recollections

[Note: Reproduced from a letter to George T. James, May 11, 1996.]

Dear Tom;

As an aid to your search for crews, I was a member of the original cadre of the 391st. I was assigned to Lloyd Stanfield as his co-pilot, from 21st Bomb Group at McDill. Albert N. Hasson was our bombardier. I can't remember the radio operator or the engineer but the tail gunner was named Shultz.

In mid summer at Myrtle Beach, the tail gunner and engineer were shipped to heavy bombardment, and I was checked out as a first pilot. Most of the other copilots also went to the heavies. This was at the time of the shut down by the Truman commission. The squadron was very short of flying personel, and we flew often with only three in a crew.

By the early fall when we went to Godman Field I had aquired a radioman named J. C. Hardwick a tail gunner named Butera and a bombardier named Donald Clark Godfrey.

One Saturday, that fall, Godfrey and I reported to the post, and found ourselves scheduled to fly to McDill for spare parts, with Arlie Watkinson as pilot. We had planned to take our wives to the football game that afternoon. No such luck. At the last minute, I was taken off the flight because my flight time for the month was already too high. Alan Seiler replaced me as copilot, and Hardwick went as radio gunner.

On the return to Godman, they had an engine failure on takeoff, and crashed in Tampa Bay, trying to reach Peter O. Knight field. Godfrey and Seiler never surfaced. Hardwick and Watkinson and an engineering officer were rescued but Hardwick was so broken up that he died the next day.

Later in the fall, I had picked up a full crew. George J. Higbee was radio gunner, Salvadore R. Ramos was engineer gunner, Butera was tail gunner, Marvin Emil Krinke was copilot, and Phillip D. Hinton who had been Seiler's bombardier replaced Don Godfrey in my crew.

When orders came for shipping overseas, it was considered that Arlie Watkinson, still recovering from the crash could not pass the physical at the POE [Port Of Embarkation?]. He was sent by air as my copilot. Krinke, and Higbee went by ship. I considered Butera insufficient, at this time, and he was replaced at tail gunner by Stanley NMI Lund. Lund also went by ship.

Thus my crew for the entire operational period of 68 missions until relieved in Sept 1944 was as follows 1st Lt. Robert Wiatt Garwick, Harrison NY, pilot; 1st Lt Phillip D. Hinton, Greenwich Conn, bombardier; 2nd Lt Marvin Emil Krinke, Lodi Wisc, co-pilot; Staff Sgt George J. Higbee, Jamaica Plain MA, radio gunner; Salvador Ramon Ramos, Glendale CA, engineer gunner; Stanley NMI Lund, Clatskanie Ore, tail gunner. L. D. Sholar was our crew chief and Eric M. Chipman, Chelmsford MA, and Angelo Debello, Westbury NY were on our ground crew. Our airplane, "Powerful Katrinka" (named for my wife) was #295841, and bore the letters 4U - S for sugar. After my tour was complete it was flown by Jim Bishoff and his crew. It was shot down on the mission to Arweiler on Xmas Eve 1944, Lt Donelly and crew. We were in D flight led by Stanley NMI Bird. I generally flew in the #2 position on Bird's right wing with Stanfield on the left wing.

Higbee, Lund and Krinke are now all members of the great squadron in the sky, Ramos is whereabouts unknown, and Hinton and I are all that's left of the fearless young men and their wonderful flying machine.

I hope this will help you

Bob Garwick