Dunn's Escape

[Note: This article was obtained from the now defunct "Wings Of Courage", 391st Bomb Group Association newsletter, November 2010.]

December 2, 1944, The target was an oil storage depot at Saarlautern, Germany. Eighteen planes of the 391st took off each carrying sixteen 250 pound fragmentation bombs, climbed in formation through the clouds to locate the pathfinder plane and assembled their three flights with it in the lead. First Lt. Edmund B. Dunn was flying #4 in the first flight. Briefing indicated there would be a solid cloud cover and that they would not be able to see their target. However, at 10,000 feet, just as they approached the target with bomb bay doors open, the clouds broke away under them and they became exposed to ground observation making the run even more dangerous. Once committed to the bomb run, the lead bombardier needs three to five minutes of straight and level flying to sight the target.

The first salvo from the 88mm canons was really close. With the second, a shell entered Ed's plane directly under the upper turret and exploded killing the gunner, tearing out the main supporting beam of the fuselage, and blowing the bombs askew in their racks. Another shell struck the plane, and fragments smashed Ed's right elbow and ankle, and blood was pouring from his boot and jacket arm. The plane rolled into a steep left bank and there was no response to the rudder. Ed and his copilot, 1st. Lt. Edwin H. Armstrong managed to control the plane using the engines and ailerons and tried to drop the bombs over the target with no success. Bombardier T/Sgt. Oliver W. Hartwell rendered first aid to Lt Dunn, then went back with the copilot to assess the damage. There was pure chaos! The main structural beam was blown away, gaping holes throughout, and only a small piece of skin holding the tail section on. The top turret was blown away, along with the gunner, S/Sgt. Jesse M. Ellerbe. The waist gunner, T/Sgt. James B. Simms, was alive but riddled with fragments. The tail gunner, S/Sgt. John J. Wagner, was recovering from concussion and attempting to help Simms ( he had tied a cord to Simm's parachute rip cord to enable it to open if it became necessary to push him out before crashing ). There was no access to anything behind the main bomb bay. The stern part of the plane swung back and forth and the whole tail section appeared about to rip off at any moment. The control cables to the rudder had been severed as had the hydraulic lines for landing gear and propeller control. The electric system including the radio was out.

They concluded that they could not abandon the plane and the injured Simms, and that they would try to return to base where they could get medical aid. The flight leader, Boylan, returned to guide them back but soon lost contact in the clouds as they started a slow descent from 7,000 feet on a compass heading they hoped would take them to the area of the home base. For more than an hour they maintained 200 m.p.h. so as to keep from stalling. When they decided they should be somewhere over level terrain in central France they let down very carefully until they could see the ground and hopefully a place to land. Flying at less than 100 feet, they found themselves over a valley with a canal in it. Was it the "Oise" canal? If so, their base would be about 100 miles to the northwest.

The tail section had held on up to now; with no gauges functioning, they calculated there was enough fuel for another hour flight if there were no leaks in the tanks. Having reset their altimeter from ground level, Dunn started a slow easy climbing turn to the northwest to about 1,000 feet and maintained course for another half hour. Then again letting down they broke out in the rain at about 100 feet searching for some landmark that would give a clue as to their location. Suddenly, through the rain and mist they spotted an airstrip about one-half mile ahead - PULL UP, PULL UP, FULL POWER ON!! The runway was full of bomb craters.

Continuing on at about 100 feet, they looked for distinctive landmarks. Copilot Armstrong spotted on their map two railroad tracks that crossed at right angles. They guessed one of them must run toward their base - follow that track! Dunn was losing control of the electric props, his only means of direction control. Thank God, they spotted the towers of the Roi-Amy church. Home field was just a short distance southeast of it. They spotted the runway and lined up on it carefully letting down with no wheels, bomb bay doors open, sixteen 250 pound armed bombs dangling there. Cutting the power and feathering the props hampered directional control - Ed dropped the right wing, pulled over, rolled out and set the plane down at 160 m.p.h. It slid about 4,000 feet and stopped in the center of the runway - no fire!

Medics removed Simms who was barely alive and did all they could for him. Ironically, Lt. Dunn's regular engineer gunner was not available for the flight, so Sgt. Ellerbe volunteered for the flight to fill the last of his 65 mission tour. Ed Dunn fully recovered from his wounds and returned to duty. For his bravery and flying skill, he was awarded the Distinguished Flying Cross which was pinned on him by Gen. "Hap" Arnold.

ADDENDUM: In a letter to George T. James, Edwin H. Armstrong (CP) wrote that their regular Crew Chief [EG or FE] and Top-Turret Gunner was grounded and demoted because he threw a punch at the O.D. [Officer of the Day?] the night before [this mission]!